Gov. Rick Scott’s High Speed Rail Decision Understandable But Wrong

Gov. Rick Scott’s decision Wednesday to block the high speed rail line from Tampa to Orlando was a surprise to me.

Maybe I’m just naive, but I figured he would hear enough persuasive arguments about the long-term benefits of high speed rail from proponents such as state Sen. Paula Dockery that he would take the federal government’s $2.4 billion and move forward with the project.

But Scott was swayed by the other side, the side that got him elected. This is why his decision is understandable. There is a huge anti-spending sentiment in the country right now, and rightfully so considering our precarious debt situation.That sentiment carried Scott into Tallahassee.

When I first heard about the Obama administration’s plan to spend $8 billion on high speed rail I thought, “What a waste!” I’d rather see that money spent on improving and maintaining our current infrastructure that is in decay and some places and in need of expansion in others.

And high speed rail would cost Florida taxpayers more than $200 million, and I can understand Scott’s desire to save every penny he can, where he can. I agree with that mind-set.

But there are some key differences between the high speed rail project and your run-of-the-mill government programs.

First, the federal money was only going to be directed toward high speed rail. There’s no point in arguing over whether it should be spent on ports or highways or bridges, because this money was never going to be used for that. By saying no to high speed rail, Scott is saying no to the full $2.4 billion.

Second, there was plenty of opportunity to require whatever private firms build the project to actually cover the remaining construction costs and any future overruns or revenue shortfalls. The overrun liability is key, because I don’t think high speed rail is going to make money for a while, especially the Tampa-Orlando line. It’s also likely to be more expensive to build than projected, as almost anything of this magnitude is.

Scott is right to be worried about taxpayers being forced to subsidize the project in the future, but he didn’t even have a bid process to see if any firms would be willing to bite that bullet. If no company stepped up and took on that responsibility, then fine, block the project. But I’ve read where seven groups of companies were ready to come to the table and make a deal, so Scott should have at least listened to their bids.

Third, this was an incredible opportunity to invest in America’s future and to make Florida a leader in new technologies. I truly believe high speed rail is going to happen eventually in this country, and Florida would have been uniquely positioned as a key player in the national system’s development had this project gone through. Now we’re on the sidelines and could be left licking the scraps off the floor for years to come.

While I don’t think the Tampa-Orlando line will be profitable or that attractive for riders in general, the line would have eventually gone to Miami, and then possibly to Gainesville, Jacksonville and Tallahassee. At some point it would connect with Atlanta, and Washington, and New York, Chicago and St. Louis. As the national network expands, the benefits of high speed rail become more apparent and we could have a viable alternative to driving or flying, just as Europe does.

But, for now, driving is significantly cheaper in America than it is in Europe, and it’s still more convenient for us to hop in the car for a trip than to take a train. I just don’t think that will be the case forever, as gas prices are sure to rise and traffic will continue to put more of a strain on our current infrastructure. At some point rail is going to become a viable option.

With Scott’s decision, however, Florida loses the opportunity to prepare for the future and ensure that our transportation needs are secure when we no longer view driving or flying as the best ways to travel. I appreciate his desire to control spending and protect taxpayers, but this was not the best way to do it.

Hopefully the state will get another crack at the project down the road.

This entry was posted in Government. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Gov. Rick Scott’s High Speed Rail Decision Understandable But Wrong

  1. HeartofFlorida says:

    This is why you should never trust a proven crook.

    Florida has been in this position twice and lost twice due to deception and greed. Two times, Florida has had companies (Flour-Bombardier in 2003, several unnamed companies currently) in place ready to assume operating costs and cover the risks associated with the project (that means losses as well). To make this even more of a travesty, unlike the terms of the bidding process last decade where Florida was expected to spend the initial $2.3 Billion (with reimbursement from Flour-Bombardier over a 30 year period), the State of Florida didn’t have to spend a penny, not one. Just sit back, let the construction begin and truly Get People To Work.

    What does our illustrious RickLet’s get to workScott do? He pulls the plug before the bidding takes place. He pulls the plug before the official numbers for the project were released. What this means is that he NEVER had intentions of going through with the project. He allowed municipalities and various entities (local, state, and federal) to waste time and precious resources on a project that he was never going to allow to go forward. He could have denied the funds immediately upon taking office but instead decided to wait for some…..arbitrary date in his head I guess.

    Thank you again, Rick Scott! I’d also like to thank the voters of this state for enabling a proven crook to enter office. I really hope all the teachers, law enforcement, state employees and public servants that voted for Tricky Ricky sealed their own demise.

    Next round of furloughs/layoffs up next. Stay tuned…..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s